It’s been over a decade since VirnetX – often called a patent troll – began a lot of lawsuits in opposition to Apple. Now after 13 years, it seems the battle between the 2 corporations is over because the Supreme Courtroom has denied a bid by VirnetX to revive a $503 million patent case.
It’s been an extended highway between VirnetX and Apple. The previous filed one in every of its first lawsuits in opposition to the iPhone maker again in 2012. And after 9 years of litigation, Apple paid a $454 million settlement in 2020.
Nevertheless, there was one other set of prices associated to FaceTime, VPN, and iMessage patents that VirnetX claimed Apple was responsible of infringing.
A jury in East Texas awarded VirnetX $502 million in damages for that lawsuit in 2018, however Apple instantly appealed the ruling within the Federal Circuit.
In March 2023, Apple was awarded a ruling by the U.S. Courtroom of Appeals for the Federal Circuit that VirnetX’s second set of patent claims had been invalid.
Nevertheless, VirnetX then appealed to the Supreme Courtroom to listen to the case.
Quick ahead to at this time, the Supreme Courtroom introduced it’s declining to listen to the $503 million case (by way of CNBC). Meaning the Federal Circuit determination dominated in favor of Apple stands.
President Biden’s representatives from the Patent Workplace additionally sided with Apple on the matter, urging “the justices to reject the case.”
VirnetX complained “that former patent workplace interim director Drew Hirshfeld, who presided earlier than Vidal was appointed, exceeded his authority by denying VirnetX’s requests for director evaluate of the choices.”
For its half, Apple argued that VirnetX’s “arguments weren’t supported by relevant federal regulation.”
FTC: We use revenue incomes auto affiliate hyperlinks. Extra.
