The Samsung Galaxy S24 Extremely’s HDR playback ruined motion pictures for me

The Samsung Galaxy S24 sequence packs arguably the most effective {hardware} specs within the enterprise, from a speedy processor to sturdy construct high quality. The splendid AMOLED show, particularly, is a long-running sequence spotlight, however having spent a couple of hours watching HDR motion pictures on my new Galaxy S24 Extremely, I’m left a bit upset.

At first, I assumed it had one thing to do with my film file, so I went onto YouTube and located some HDR movies to check these too. Whereas watching SDR content material, every thing regarded as I might anticipate. Nevertheless, with HDR, the image seems dim and the highlights aren’t even that shiny, regardless of Samsung’s claims of two,600 nits of peak brightness. Total, the presentation regarded muted and uninteresting.

So, I examined it towards my Google Pixel 8 Professional and Apple iPhone 15 Professional, and lo and behold, the S24 Extremely confirmed constantly decrease peak brightness numbers than each of those gadgets. Considerably decrease, actually. Practically 40% much less brightness than the iPhone when displaying at peak white, masking 50% of the display. Simply to offer you an concept, even in comparison with an previous iPhone 11 Professional Max, a handset that claims a mere 1,200 nits of peak brightness, the Galaxy S24 nonetheless regarded dimmer and offered much less distinction when displaying real-world content material.

I re-ran my assessments nicely over 4 occasions (I misplaced rely at that time); I went into the settings to allow the excessive brightness mode, made positive to check the cellphone with and with out adaptive brightness, and checked vivid mode and pure mode. I even ran each HDR10 and HDR10+ movies, simply to verify it didn’t have something to do with the dynamic metadata of HDR10+, however nothing appeared to make a distinction.

That was till I began to mess around with ambient gentle brightness, and the problem grew to become as clear as day. A type of adaptive brightness is all the time enabled for HDR content material on the S24 sequence. Within the video above, you may see the show’s brightness rise in clear steps as I enhance the room’s brightness, although adaptive brightness is off and mustn’t intrude with brightness in such a drastic approach when displaying HDR content material.

This results in some annoying results. For those who’re watching HDR content material indoors with solely oblique gentle, Samsung’s software program lowers the show’s brightness it doesn’t matter what settings you could have on. This not solely creates photos that lack the glowing highlights that OLEDs are so good at reproducing, however it additionally makes the darker components of the picture darker than they need to be.

That’s a mistake. The whole level of HDR is to regulate the distinction as a lot as doable, so screens mustn’t intrude with the creator’s supposed distinction ratio for a specific scene.

The exception could be boosting brightness for accessibility causes. I suppose, in case you’re watching a film or TV present exterior, in direct, shiny gentle, it’s higher to see a boosted picture than no picture in any respect. Nonetheless, I solely see that as an accessibility characteristic that must be toggled on and off, not the default utilized in all viewing eventualities.

Maybe worse, you too can see the display shift colour barely, making subtler blues into extra vibrant and intense hues. It appears like Samsung is attempting to trick my eyeballs into preferring it, to the detriment of accuracy and respecting the unique image.

We reached out to Samsung for a proof of the conduct and whether or not it’s intentional or not. Right here’s what Samsung needed to say:

“Adaptive Brightness drives show changes primarily based on the ambient gentle degree. Samsung Galaxy gadgets course of HDR movies to regulate the luminance of the show adaptively primarily based on not solely present show brightness, but in addition viewing situations. That is to offer enhanced visibility and a extra immersive viewing expertise to customers, finest showcasing the excessive dynamic vary of HDR video belongings.​”

So that is intentional, with Samsung’s software program compensating for ambient viewing situations to attempt to enhance the look of HDR movies. I’m not satisfied it really works very nicely.

Each Samsung system that we tried, together with the vanilla Galaxy S24, S24 Extremely, and S23 Extremely, behaved very equally. With out a toggle to show this on and off, adaptive brightness is how Samsung seems to deal with HDR video on all its flagship telephones.

On the plus facet, environmental adaptability will help enhance visibility, notably outside, the place daylight could make it arduous to see the show. The truth that Samsung’s show isn’t as super-bright as telephones that declare absurd figures like 4,000 nits of peak brightness isn’t essentially a problem by itself. Sustaining constant distinction together with excessive brightness is what’s essential. Nevertheless, that requires adaptability to be dealt with the fitting approach.

Sadly, Samsung’s method produces visible artifacts. For one, you may typically see the brightness stepping up with modifications in ambient gentle. That is fairly distracting whereas mid-movie, notably in case you are on public transport and go in a tunnel that quickly modifications the ambient gentle. Annoyingly, the transition is nowhere close to as easy because the default auto brightness that scales it in a way more nice approach. It’s fairly abrupt.

That’s along with the shadow-crushing, color-skewing, and relatively dim presentation with indoor lighting that detracts from the standard (and function) of HDR video. Finally a toggle to show HDR adaptive brightness on and off would go well with each worlds. Given the swathes of current show choices, a “filmmaker mode” for HDR wouldn’t take a lot so as to add. Make it so, Samsung?