Greatest Pillow-High Mattresses for 2024

In case you are searching for a mushy but supportive mattress made with quite a lot of supplies, a pillow-top mattress is your greatest guess. An enormous key to a great pillow high mattress is providing reduction from stress in your physique and movement isolation to maintain your physique feeling good. The reminiscence foam, cotton, latex and wool these mattresses are produced from assist supply various things for various sleep wants.

A number of choices can be found for changing your present mattress with a pillow-top mattress. I’ve performed the arduous half for you by spending hours upon hours laying on beds which have mattress topper consolation layers (it is a tough gig, I do know), doing my greatest to explain how every mattress sort feels while you sleep and whether or not I believe it is well worth the cash. I really like pillow high mattresses and have been sleeping on one for a number of years now. I do not love the texture of reminiscence foam, however I benefit from the ethereal cushioning pillow high mattresses present.

On this mattress roundup, I reveal the most effective pillow high mattress choices from my expertise as a mattress tester. 

What’s the greatest pillow high mattress?

For everybody who needs to get straight to it, the Star Hybrid from Bear earned the highest spot right here as the most effective pillow high mattress. It is ultra-comfortable, has a fluffy quilted high, and the quilt is made with a particular sleep-boosting, recovery-aid materials known as Celliant that is not discovered in lots of mattresses. 

Video: Greatest pillow high mattress

Watch CNET video producer Owen Poole assessment the most effective pillow high mattresses.

The costs beneath are for queen measurement fashions and had been lately up to date.

Greatest pillow high mattresses of 2024

Sort Hybrid mattressFirmness Medium or 5Trial 365 nightsGuarantee Lifetime guarantee Worth $$$

Why we picked the Bear Star Hybrid: The pillow high of the Star Hybrid mattress is infused with Celliant, a material containing sure thermo-reactive supplies. It absorbs your physique warmth and transfers it again to you as infrared vitality. In flip, it boosts your blood circulation and oxygen, serving to you’re feeling extra energized while you get up. I am unable to say this tech works indisputably, however I can say it is a very snug pillow-top mattress.

Though it incorporates a number of layers of froth, it looks like an opulent pillow high on a supportive innerspring system. It is like a conventional innerspring mattress, solely 10 instances extra snug. Just like the pillow high beds on this checklist, it is also accommodating for all physique sorts. Additionally, like a variety of bed-in-a-box manufacturers named on this checklist, they provide fairly beneficiant reductions all year long to make your mattress even cheaper.

Execs:

• Thick, fluffy pillow high
• Pocketed coil layer
• Appropriate for any sleeper
• Celliant materials

Cons:

Bear Hybrid

Sort Hybrid mattressFirmness 3 firmness ranges | Plush Gentle: Medium or 5 | Luxurious Agency: Medium-firm or 7 | Agency: 9/10 or agencyTrial 365 nightsGuarantee Lifetime guarantee Worth $$

Why we picked the Saatva Traditional: The Saatva innerspring mattress is the most effective pillow-top mattress for again ache as a result of it provides a ton of help with out compromising fluffy stress reduction. This mattress jogs my memory of a flowery resort mattress you’d sleep on when on a pleasant trip. The consolation layer high feels good and fluffy, however extra substantial and supportive than normal cotton fluff due to the pressure-relieving reminiscence foam layer. The mattress topper has an eggshell-colored, natural cotton Euro pillow high. 

It is obtainable in two totally different heights and three firmness ranges. Select between 11.5 inches or 14.5 inches for the last word physique help. The softest pillow high possibility is round a medium or 5 on my firmness scale, and it solely will get firmer from there. The queen mattress has 884 individually pocketed coils, lowering movement switch. My favourite is the “Plush Gentle” however heavy sleepers with again ache ought to think about “Agency.”

Execs:

• Tremendous supportive and sturdy
• Twin coil system
• Good for spinal alignment
• Good worth for the standard

Cons:

• Too agency for petite sleepers
• Not a mushy mattress

Learn our full Saatva mattress assessment for extra.

Saatva Traditional

* Pricing based mostly on Queen mannequin

Sort Hybrid mattressFirmness 3 firmness ranges | Softer: Medium-soft or 3 | Luxurious agency: Medium or 5 | Firmer: Medium-firm or 7Trial 120 nightsGuarantee Lifetime guarantee Worth $$

Why we picked the WinkBed: This mattress from WinkBed, made with gel foam, is the epitome of a luxurious mattress and deserves a high spot on our checklist for the most effective pillow-top mattress. The quilt is a shiny white colour with blue and white polka dot detailing across the edge. The within is the true star of the present. The plush Euro pillow-top mattress looks like one large ethereal cloud on high of a supportive and sturdy system of pocketed coils.

It is obtainable in three totally different firmness ranges: Softer, Luxurious Agency and Firmer mattress choices. Aspect sleepers ought to think about the pressure-relieving Softer mannequin and it is probably the greatest mushy pillow high mattresses I’ve examined. On the flip aspect, again and abdomen sleepers could actually just like the help provided by the Agency WinkBed. 

Execs:

• Appropriate to any sleeper
• Additional-edge-support system
• Three firmness ranges

Cons:

• Too costly for price range consumers

The WinkBed

Sort Reminiscence foam hybridFirmness Medium or 5Trial 100 nightsGuarantee 10-year guarantee Worth $$

Why we picked the Allswell Supreme: The perfect pillow-top mattress choices aren’t at all times probably the most inexpensive beds in the marketplace. The Allswell Supreme mattress from retail big Walmart provides the identical cushiony supportive really feel at a extra accessible price. 

It is a thick 14 inches and incorporates 5 totally different layers. This consists of pocketed coils, their particular Energex foam, graphite and copper-infused reminiscence foam and a fluffy Euro-top. This mattress has a reminiscence foam really feel, extra so than any of the opposite beds on this checklist. It is not as distinguished as a Nectar mattress, however you do really feel the mattress topper layers hug your physique as you grow to be nestled into the mattress. It is also extra bouncy than typical reminiscence foam, particularly due to the pocketed coil layer within the basis.

It is solely a hair firmer than a medium on the firmness scale, I would give it a 5 and a half out of 10, the place 10 is probably the most agency. Even so, it’s pressure-relieving sufficient for aspect sleepers and supportive sufficient to maintain a again and abdomen sleeper’s backbone in correct alignment. It is price noting the model additionally provides a flagship Allswell mattress at an much more inexpensive worth. 

Execs:

• Nice price range selection
• Fits any physique sort

Cons:

• Primary wanting
• Has a definite reminiscence foam really feel which some individuals do not life

Allswell Supreme

Sort Poly foam hybrid mattressFirmness 5 or mediumTrial 100 nightsGuarantee 15-year restricted guarantee Worth $$$

Why we picked the Helix Midnight Luxe: {Couples} sometimes need a mattress that’ll accommodate each of their sleeping kinds and physique sorts and has distinctive edge help and movement isolation. The Helix Midnight Luxe mattress does this, making it our decide for the most effective pillow high mattress for {couples}.

It is 14 inches thick and has six totally different layers inside. The pocketed coil layer within the base makes use of lumbar help coils, offering softer reduction below your shoulders and focused help to your decrease again and trunk. It is not tremendous noticeable while you lay down, however in the long term, this building element helps promote correct alignment and forestall again ache.

This pillow-top mattress has a skinny layer of gel reminiscence foam, which makes the pillow high barely extra foamy-feeling. It is what I might describe as a traditional, neutral-foam really feel. The pillow high neutralizes the reminiscence foam really feel, whereas the reminiscence foam takes away the pillow-top mattress’s airiness. 

Execs:

• Anybody will prefer it
• Textured pillow high
• Versatile medium firmness

Cons:

• Not as ethereal as different pillow tops
• Not a price range selection

Learn our full Helix mattress assessment for extra. 

Helix Midnight Luxe

What to contemplate when looking for the most effective pillow high mattress

Sleeping place

The way you sleep will largely decide how agency a mattress you should purchase. Abdomen and again sleepers want firmer pillow high mattresses that supply sufficient help to maintain their backbone aligned. Abdomen sleepers are likely to fall on the softer aspect of the dimensions due to the stress reduction provided to the shoulders, hips and knees. 

Your physique sort additionally performs a task on this. The lighter you might be, the tougher a mattress will appear. The heavier you might be, the softer it can really feel. 

Development

What the mattress is produced from is one other issue you need to think about when looking for a pillow-top mattress. The development of the mattress will decide how supportive it’s. Foam mattresses will typically at all times be much less supportive than hybrid mattresses with layers of pocketed coils. 

Worth

Mattresses are a giant buy. It is essential to know your price range when procuring on your subsequent mattress. There are a number of pillow-top mattress selections at each price range stage. The excellent news is that the majority manufacturers do large reductions across the holidays, so you will get a pair hundred off the worth tag of your subsequent mattress for those who time it proper. 

How we take a look at pillow high mattresses

Our mattress testing specialists have examined over 100 mattresses and counting. We’re actually good at testing beds and assessing them for what the typical individual wants and values. Whereas testing, we think about a number of key elements that assist us assess every mattress. 

CNET editors decide the services we write about based mostly on editorial advantage. If you purchase by way of our hyperlinks, we could get a fee. Learn extra on how we take a look at mattresses.

Firmness and really feel

We begin with the 2 most essential elements concerning mattresses: firmness and really feel. You may take into consideration firmness as how arduous or mushy the mattress is. I do know what you are pondering, who needs a tough mattress? Loads of stress reduction is not at all times the best choice for everybody, however some individuals, like abdomen and again sleepers, want a firmer mattress with extra help to maintain their backbone aligned at night time. Aspect sleepers, however, do profit from a softer mattress that gives stress reduction for his or her shoulders, hips and knees. We charge firmness on a 1 to 10 scale, corresponding with phrases like “medium” or “medium-firm.”

The texture is the opposite large one we notice instantly. What does the pillow high mattress really feel like while you’re mendacity on it? Does it have the sinking reminiscence foam really feel or a extra impartial foam that bounces again shortly? Particularly for pillow tops, we keep in mind how thick they’re and what really feel they offer the mattress. How agency and what the mattress looks like is famous in each assessment. 

Efficiency

We think about a number of efficiency elements when testing the most effective pillow high mattresses. The primary is edge help — how structured the perimeter of the mattress is. Testing this is so simple as sitting on the sting of the mattress and assessing how supportive it’s. If we really feel like we’ll fall off the mattress by sitting on the sting, then it would not have nice edge help. 

Movement isolation is essential for those who sleep with a associate who tosses and turns or has a special sleeping schedule than you. We take a look at this by inserting a glass of water on the mattress and rolling throughout the mattress to see if it can tip over. We additionally know the way properly the mattress distributes warmth and regulates temperature. 

Different pillow high mattresses we have examined

This greatest pillow high mattress checklist was curated by our CNET Sleep editors, who’ve had their fair proportion of laying on beds. They’ve examined over 100 totally different beds and have hours of expertise below their belts. The picks proven above proved to be a few of their favorites, however the beds we have examined beneath are additionally within the working for consideration. 

DreamCloud mattress: The DreamCloud mattress is a thick hybrid mattress made with new-age reminiscence foam. It is rated round a 5 on the firmness spectrum or round a medium, making it best for almost any sleeping place. 

Loom & Leaf mattress: The Loom & Leaf mattress is from the posh on-line mattress model Saatva. It is a conforming reminiscence foam mattress made with out coils, and it has a cooling gel layer that does a great job of conserving your temperature impartial. The pillow high is made with totally different consolation foams and it even options its Lumbar Zone Quilting, which supplies focused help to your lumbar area. It is available in two totally different firmness ranges, however they each lean towards the agency aspect (medium-firm and agency). 

Avocado Inexperienced mattress: The Avocado mattress is a inexperienced mattress made with environmentally pleasant supplies sourced from nature which might be non-toxic, hypoallergenic and antimicrobial. You may add a pillow high made with natural latex foam and natural cotton for added consolation. With the pillow high, Avocado is rated round a medium firmness.